I’ve been ordering ButcherBox since 2018, and honestly, it’s become one of my favorite ways to keep high-quality meat stocked in my freezer for weekly meal prep and busy weeknight dinners.
But is ButcherBox actually worth the cost?
In this honest ButcherBox review, I’m sharing my experience after years of ordering, the meats I think are absolutely worth buying, how I make ButcherBox work within my grocery budget, and why I think it’s especially helpful for busy working moms and families.
This post contains affiliate links. I am an affiliate for Amazon Associates and other brands and earn a small commission on qualifying purchases. You’re by no means obligated to use my links but, if you do, thank you for supporting Organize Yourself Skinny. Please see our review process for more information on how I review products, services, and companies.
Quick Look at ButcherBox
- What is ButcherBox? A subscription meat delivery service offering high-quality beef, chicken, pork, seafood, and specialty meats delivered frozen right to your door.
- How much does ButcherBox cost? Pricing varies depending on the box size and customization options, but most custom boxes start around $169/month.
- Can you customize your box? Yes. You can choose curated boxes or fully customize your own box with your favorite cuts of meat and seafood.
- Who is ButcherBox best for? Busy families, healthy meal prep, high-protein eating, and anyone who values convenience and wants high-quality meat delivered directly to their home.
- Who probably shouldn’t bother? People who rarely cook at home, don’t have freezer space, already have easy access to affordable high-quality meat locally, or don’t mind spending the time shopping at multiple grocery stores.
- What’s the latest ButcherBox deal? ButcherBox frequently offers free meat, discounts, or bonus items for new members.
👉 CHECK TODAY’S BUTCHERBOX NEW MEMBER DEAL
Why I’ve Continued Ordering ButcherBox Since 2018
I’ve been a ButcherBox customer since 2018, and every 1-2 months, I order a large custom box and build meal plans around the meat to fit our grocery budget.
Back in 2018, grocery delivery services and subscription boxes were just starting to become popular. At that point, I was already ordering a lot of organic pantry staples from Thrive Market, so I figured I’d give ButcherBox a try too.
After receiving my first box, I was hooked.
The quality of the meat was noticeably better, the selection was excellent, and honestly, there’s just something about a box of high-quality meat showing up at your doorstep that makes life feel easier.
As someone who cooks most meals at home, meal preps regularly, and likes to keep my freezer stocked with healthy proteins, ButcherBox fits perfectly into my lifestyle.
I still shop locally too. I live in Buffalo, NY, so I have access to many great grocery stores. But I still continue to order ButcherBox because, while the prices can sometimes (but, not always) be a little higher, the convenience is worth it for my busy schedule.
I also love that I can customize my box based on what my family actually eats. Instead of randomly shopping for meat every week, I can plan meals ahead of time around the proteins I know we’ll use.
And, that alone saves me both time and stress.
Over the years, I’ve also tried other meat delivery services like Good Chop and Omaha Steaks, but ButcherBox continues to be my favorite because of the quality, selection, flexibility, and customer service.
And this is exactly why I happily continue to order ButcherBox year after year.
👉 CHECK TODAY’S BUTCHERBOX NEW MEMBER DEAL
What Is ButcherBox?
ButcherBox is a subscription meat delivery service that partners directly with farmers and cooperatives to deliver high-quality meat and seafood directly to consumers.
They offer:
- grass-fed and grass-finished beef
- organic chicken
- heritage-breed pork
- wild-caught seafood
- specialty meats
- and seasonal products.
One of the things I personally like most is that the meat arrives frozen and individually packaged, making it really easy to organize in the freezer and use for meal prep throughout the month.
How Does ButcherBox Work?
ButcherBox works as a subscription service, but it’s actually very flexible.
You can choose delivery frequencies every:
- 2 weeks
- 4 weeks
- 6 weeks
- or 8 weeks.
You can also:
- skip deliveries
- reschedule deliveries
- customize your box
- add extra products
- and change your meat selections before your billing date.
I personally order every 1-2 months depending on how much meat we currently have stocked in the freezer.
Is ButcherBox Worth It?
Honestly? Yes – I absolutely think ButcherBox is worth it if you prioritize high-quality meat and cook at home regularly. But even more than that, I think it’s worth it if you prioritize convenience.
At least for me, subscription services like ButcherBox aren’t necessarily about finding the absolute cheapest deal possible. They’re more about convenience, consistency, and getting high-quality products delivered to your door at a price that feels reasonable and manageable for your lifestyle.
If your only goal is finding the absolute lowest price on chicken or ground beef, then shopping local sales or buying bulk meat at Costco, BJ’s, or Sam’s Club may make more sense for your budget.
But, in my opinion, where ButcherBox really shines is in the:
- quality
- convenience
- consistency
- selection
- and accessibility.
In my experience, the prices are often very comparable to high-quality organic meats sold locally. Sometimes they’re slightly more expensive, and sometimes they’re actually cheaper depending on the cut and the store.
But what keeps me ordering is the convenience of always having high-quality proteins stocked in my freezer without having to run to multiple grocery stores hoping they’re available and in stock.
As a busy working mom who meal preps regularly and cooks most meals at home, that convenience is worth a lot to me.
👉 CHECK TODAY’S BUTCHERBOX NEW MEMBER DEAL
My Favorite ButcherBox Meats
One of the biggest reasons I continue ordering from ButcherBox is because the quality of the meat is consistently excellent.
Some of my favorite meats to order include:
- top sirloin steaks
- flat iron steaks
- boneless skinless chicken breasts
- boneless pork butt
- chuck roast
- ground turkey
- ground Italian sausage
- bacon
- and ground beef.
They also have delicious seafood options. I especially love the:
- shrimp
- scallops
- and salmon.
Not to mention, they have gluten-free chicken nuggets that I absolutely love and honestly get excited about whenever they show up in my box. They also offer hot dogs, pre-cooked chicken sausage, and other healthier convenience items like that, which can make busy weeknights so much easier.
Another thing worth mentioning is that I’ve also ordered their turkeys for Thanksgiving and hams for Easter – and honestly, they were some of the best I’ve ever had.
What I really love is that I know I’m always getting high-quality protein that tastes good and works well in the kinds of meals my family actually eats every week. It takes a lot of the guesswork and frustration out of grocery shopping, especially during busy seasons when stores are crowded or constantly out of stock.
👉 SEE TODAY’S BUTCHERBOX DEAL HERE
How I Make ButcherBox Affordable for My Family
One of the biggest questions people ask is how I fit ButcherBox into our grocery budget.
And honestly, the biggest thing that helps is meal planning around the meat we receive.
When I first started ordering ButcherBox, I used curated boxes. But eventually, I switched to custom boxes because it made meal planning so much easier.
Now I can:
- choose the cuts we actually eat
- build meal plans around those proteins
- stock up during sales
- and stretch proteins across multiple meals.
For example:
- I can turn two sirloin steaks into steak fajitas for four people
- use one chuck roast for several meals
- or stretch chicken breasts across multiple shredded chicken recipes.
I also take advantage of:
- member deals
- add-ons
- seasonal bundles
- and stock-up promotions.
Those deals can make a huge difference in overall value.
👉 CHECK TODAY’S BUTCHERBOX NEW MEMBER DEAL
What I Don’t Love About ButcherBox
To keep this review honest, there are definitely a few downsides.
First, ButcherBox can feel expensive upfront, especially if you order larger custom boxes or add extra products and bundles.
Second, you absolutely need freezer space. If your freezer is already packed, storing a large meat delivery can be difficult.
And finally, if you don’t cook at home regularly, ButcherBox may not be worth the investment.
For me personally, the value comes from the convenience of having high-quality meat delivered directly to my door, which drastically reduces the amount of time I spend grocery shopping each week.
It also fits perfectly with the way I cook and eat. I cook most meals at home, prioritize high-quality protein, and like knowing the meat I’m feeding my family comes from farmers and producers that focus on quality and responsible practices.
ButcherBox vs Costco, BJ’s, and Sam’s Club
Wholesale clubs like Costco, BJ’s, and Sam’s Club have definitely improved their organic meat options over the years.
And honestly, there are times when they may offer better pricing on basic cuts like chicken breasts or ground beef.
However, what I personally find better about ButcherBox is:
- the convenience
- the consistency
- the quality
- and the wider variety of specialty cuts.
I also like knowing I can order exactly what I want online instead of hoping it’s available at the store.
If you already shop wholesale regularly, I think it’s worth comparing prices locally to see what works best for your family and budget.
👉 CHECK TODAY’S BUTCHERBOX NEW MEMBER DEAL
Who Will Love ButcherBox
ButcherBox is probably a great fit for:
- busy families
- high-protein lifestyles
- people who prioritize organic or high-quality meats
- people who don’t want to spend time shopping at multiple stores
- and anyone who wants healthy proteins consistently stocked at home.
Who Probably Won’t Love ButcherBox
ButcherBox may not be the best fit if:
- you rarely cook at home
- you don’t have freezer space
- you’re only looking for the cheapest meat possible
- or you already have easy access to affordable high-quality meats locally and don’t mind going to grocery stores.
My Final Thoughts on ButcherBox
After ordering ButcherBox consistently since 2018, I can honestly say it’s one of my favorite services for keeping high-quality proteins stocked in my freezer.
I love the convenience, the quality, the flexibility, and how much easier it makes meal prep and healthy eating during busy weeks.
Is it the cheapest option for buying meat? Not always.
But for me personally, the convenience, consistency, and quality make ButcherBox absolutely worth it.
And if you’re someone who meal preps, cooks at home regularly, or wants easier access to high-quality proteins, I definitely think ButcherBox is worth looking into.
Tara says
We started Butcher Box about 4 months ago and it has been a big help to my diet. We get the tenderloin tips and grill steak kabobs marinated in sugar free Korean BBQ sauce with toms of veggies once a week. It feels like a restaurant meal without the cost or calories! And better than the fast food we used to eat.
Tammy Overhoff says
That’s great! Thanks so much for your feedback. It’s helpful.
Alisa Lignoski says
Does Butcher Box except EBT?
steve cychos says
I bought their box of meat. I cost about $340. I got rib-eye, new-york and filet-mignon, and it was all tuff. I eat grass feed beef, Prime, and it is always tender. The beef from Butcher Box was not tender at all. It was more like select from walmart. The bacon and sausage where all good and so was the sea food, but the sea food is the same that I can buy from sam’s or costco, for less. I canceled my subscription.
Reagan says
I just got my first box and signed up during a $20 off first two boxes + free first box bacon.
Also! Was looking on the site and at the bottom there is a “student” link! $20 off every box + bacon in every box through a Unidays account (easy to sign up for). Very excited to keep using this service especially with the student discount.
Tammy Kresge says
wow that’s great! I didn’t know about the student discount.
Abby says
I’ve actually had a bad experience with them. I signed up during a bacon for life offer and they will not honor it. I have a screenshot with date and time metadata on it and they are not budging. They also have forgotten things in each of the three custom boxes I received so far. They resolve to make it up by sending bacon in the next box but they’ve forgotten that all three times too…
Tammy Kresge says
I’m sorry you had that experience. I’ve had great experience with their customer service. I hope it all work out for you.
Natalie says
How did it work for you that all of the meat was frozen? I can NEVER seem to remember to thaw meat before I need it!
Tammy Kresge says
I agree! Ha! I actually prefer to freezer meat as part of a recipe. Basically, I just had to remember and plan our meals around what was in the freezer. I also thawed a few things at once when I prepped for the week.
Rex Newman says
We’re downsizing to a large apartment complex soon, so how would delivery be handled to an inside door, nothing to stop theft?
Tammy Kresge says
That a great question. I would ask the apartment complex how they handle deliveries like this. I would think it’s the same with any larger delivery. I know in my sister’s complex they deliver it right to their door (inside the complex). But I would think every complex is different.