• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Organize Yourself Skinny
  • About
  • Recipes
  • Shop Amazon Favs
  • Shop Meal Plans & Freezer Prep Guides
menu icon
go to homepage
  • About
  • Recipes
  • Shop Amazon Favs
  • Shop Meal Plans & Freezer Prep Guides
    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
  • search icon
    Homepage link
    • About
    • Recipes
    • Shop Amazon Favs
    • Shop Meal Plans & Freezer Prep Guides
    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
  • ×
    Home » Healthy Lifestyle and Weight Loss » 5 Foods That Can Help You Cut Back on Sugar

    5 Foods That Can Help You Cut Back on Sugar

    Published: Nov 4, 2026 by Tammy Overhoff

    If you’re trying to cut back on sugar but still find yourself craving something sweet, these are the five foods I personally keep around to make it easier. Over the years, I’ve learned that managing sugar cravings is less about trying to “quit sugar” completely and more about choosing naturally sweet foods, adding protein and healthy fats, reading labels, and having better options prepped and ready before the craving hits.

    These are the same strategies I’ve used in my own weight-loss journey to cut back on added and highly processed sugar without giving up foods like fruit, smoothies, or sweet potatoes. The goal isn’t perfection—it’s making a few intentional changes that help you feel fuller, more in control, and less likely to reach for something sugary out of habit.

    image with ice cream and text

    Quick Look: How I Cut Back on Added Sugar

    • My goal: Cut back on added and highly processed sugar, not eliminate naturally sweet foods like fruit.
    • What I focus on first: Coffee creamer, sweet snacks, flavored yogurt, granola, packaged breakfast foods, sauces, and anything else where added sugar can quietly add up.
    • The five foods I keep around: Fruit, Greek yogurt or cottage cheese, nuts and nut butter, oats and other high-fiber whole grains, and sweet potatoes.
    • What I pair with them: Protein and healthy fats so I actually feel full.
    • What helps the most: Meal prep. If the better choice is already washed, portioned, cooked, or sitting at the front of the refrigerator, I am much more likely to eat it.
    • My mindset: 80/20. A treat is a treat. It does not mean I failed or need to start over.

    I Don’t Try to Quit Sugar Anymore – Here’s What I Do Instead

    tammy overhoff

    When I first started paying attention to sugar, I thought the answer was simply to cut it out. What I understand now is that the bigger picture matters much more.

    Cutting back on added sugar absolutely helped with my weight loss, but so did adding more protein and healthy fats and making sure my meals and snacks were prepped ahead. Once I started doing those things together, I felt much more satisfied throughout the day instead of feeling hungry again soon after eating.

    Reading labels was another huge shift for me. I was shocked by how much added sugar could be hiding in foods I thought were healthy, especially yogurt, coffee creamer, granola, oatmeal, sauces, and packaged snacks. Once I started paying attention, I felt like I could make better decisions instead of just guessing.

    I also stopped trying to be perfect. I follow more of an 80/20 approach now. If I have cake at a birthday party or eat a Reese’s cup, I enjoy it and move on. I think of those foods as treats instead of everyday habits.

    And if I notice sugar starting to creep back into my routine, I go back to my 10-day habit approach. I focus on one change, get intentional again, and build from there. That has worked much better for me than trying to change everything at once.

    Always rooting for you!

    Natural Sugar vs. Added Sugar

    This distinction is important because I do not look at a banana the same way I look at a candy bar.

    Fruit, vegetables, and dairy contain naturally occurring sugars. They also come with other nutrients.

    Added sugars are sugars added during processing or preparation. That includes obvious things like table sugar and corn syrup, but also things like honey and maple syrup.

    So yes, pure maple syrup is still added sugar.

    The difference for me is that I can use a small amount intentionally instead of getting a large amount of added sugar without realizing it.

    That is why I focus less on trying to make my food completely sugar-free and more on being aware of how much added sugar I am eating and where it is coming from.

    5 Foods That Can Help You Cut Back on Sugar

    1. Fruit

    Fruit is still one of the first things I reach for when I want something sweet.

    I especially like berries, apples, bananas, and frozen fruit for smoothies.

    But here is one of the biggest changes I have made over the years: I usually do not eat fruit by itself anymore if I want it to actually keep me full.

    Even if the sugar is natural, I know myself. If I eat something sweet and it does not satisfy me, I am much more likely to keep looking for food.

    So I pair fruit with protein or healthy fat.

    A few combinations I use all the time:

    • Apple with peanut butter or almond butter
    • Berries with Greek yogurt
    • Frozen berries with cottage cheese
    • Banana in a smoothie with cottage cheese, Greek yogurt, protein powder, chia seeds, nut butter, or avocado
    • Fruit with cheese

    This is also how I think about my healthy smoothie recipes now.

    I love smoothies and they make me feel great, so I have no interest in taking them out of my life. But smoothies can also get very sweet very quickly when you keep adding fruit.

    I usually use berries or portion out sweeter fruits like banana, then add protein and healthy fats so the smoothie becomes an actual meal instead of just a big glass of fruit.

    If you love smoothies too, my Smoothies for Weight Loss guide walks through exactly how I build a filling smoothie with protein, fiber, healthy fats, and produce.

    One quick note on dried fruit: some dried fruit contains added sugar and some does not. Check the ingredient list and Nutrition Facts label rather than assuming either way.

    Tammy with her vitamix blender.

    2. Greek Yogurt or Cottage Cheese

    This is another place where reading labels changed things for me.

    I used to look at yogurt and just think, “This is healthy.”

    Then I started comparing labels and realized how much the added sugar can vary from one product to another.

    Now I look for options that give me protein without a lot of added sugar.

    I like Siggi’s and usually buy plain, vanilla, or raspberry depending on what I want.

    I also eat cottage cheese all the time now. One of my favorite simple snacks is cottage cheese with about 1/2 cup frozen berries.

    It is cold, creamy, naturally sweet from the fruit, and much more satisfying to me than a sweet snack by itself.

    You can also build a Greek yogurt bowl with berries, nuts, chia seeds, cinnamon, or a little nut butter.

    If plain yogurt feels too tart at first, you do not have to force yourself to suddenly love it. Start where you are. Compare brands, reduce the sweetness gradually, add your own fruit, or use a small amount of maple syrup or honey so you control how much is going in.

    The goal is not perfection. It is awareness and making a better choice more often.

    3. Nuts and Nut Butter

    I always have peanut butter and almond butter in my pantry.

    They are one of the easiest ways for me to turn something sweet into a snack that actually sticks with me.

    An apple by itself is good.

    An apple with peanut butter feels like a snack.

    The same thing happens with berries and nuts, banana and peanut butter, or oats with almond butter.

    Nuts and nut butter add fat and some protein, which is exactly what I am usually looking for when I am trying to make a snack more satisfying.

    Just check the label here too. Some nut butters have added sugar and oils, while others are basically just nuts and salt. I usually look for the simplest ingredient list I can find.

    And because nut butter is easy to overpour, I portion it when I need to. I would rather measure two tablespoons and know what I am eating than stand at the counter with a spoon and guess.

    4. Oats and Other High-Fiber Whole Grains

    I would much rather have a bowl of oats or overnight oats with some natural sweetness than eat a breakfast that is mostly added sugar and leaves me hungry an hour later.

    This is another place where I pair carbohydrates with protein and healthy fats.

    For overnight oats, that might mean adding Greek yogurt, chia seeds, nut butter, cottage cheese, or protein powder. This cottage cheese overnight oats is amazing!

    For energy balls, I like the combination of oats, nut butter, and something naturally sweet like dates. These date and chocolate energy balls are next level.

    The important part is that I am not just taking a sugary snack and calling it healthy because it has oats in it. I still look at the whole recipe.

    If I am using maple syrup, honey, dates, or chocolate chips, I pay attention to the amount. Then I ask, “What is giving me the protein? What is giving me the fiber? What is going to keep me full?”

    My Protein Overnight Oats post is a good example of how I think about this now. I show several ways to add protein so overnight oats can actually work as a filling breakfast.

    5. Sweet Potatoes

    Sweet potatoes have been one of my favorite foods for years because they are naturally sweet but still feel like part of a real meal.

    We either roast them or make them in the slow cooker, and I almost always prep them ahead. Here’s my favorite roasted sweet potatoes recipe.

    That way they are already in the refrigerator and we can warm one up with lunch or dinner instead of having to cook from scratch.

    I do not need to turn them into dessert.

    A little butter and cinnamon is plenty for me.

    You can also pair sweet potatoes with chicken, turkey, eggs, vegetables, or another protein and build a really satisfying meal around them.

    If you want to prep them ahead too, my Slow Cooker Sweet Potatoes are an easy ways to do it.

    The Strategy That Changed Everything for Me: Add Protein

    If there is one thing I understand much better now than when I originally wrote this article, it is the importance of protein.

    I used to focus much more on taking sugar away. Now I ask, “Where is the protein?”

    That one question has changed the way I build almost every meal.

    When I add cottage cheese to my smoothie, eat a protein-filled mason jar salad, or have my avocado tuna salad for lunch, I can usually make it to dinner without thinking about food all afternoon.

    When I do not eat enough protein, I notice it. I graze more.

    My regular protein staples include:

    • Eggs
    • Greek yogurt
    • Cottage cheese
    • Chicken
    • Turkey
    • Tuna
    • Protein powder

    My go-to protein powder is Garden of Life Organic Unflavored because I can add it without changing the flavor of everything else.

    I also use chia seeds, nut butter, and other ingredients to add more staying power to meals and snacks.

    If you are deciding between collagen and protein powder for smoothies, I have a full Collagen vs. Protein Powder guide that explains how I use each one.

    The goal is not to make every meal ridiculously high in protein.

    It is simply to stop eating a meal or snack that is mostly carbohydrates or sugar and then wondering why you are hungry again soon after.

    A few easy combinations:

    • Fruit + peanut butter
    • Greek yogurt + berries + nuts
    • Cottage cheese + berries
    • Eggs + fruit
    • Smoothie + protein powder or cottage cheese + chia seeds
    • Overnight oats + Greek yogurt + chia seeds
    • Chicken + roasted vegetables + rice
    • Apple + cheese

    Start With Your Coffee if That Is Your Biggest Sugar Habit

    This one is personal for me because my morning coffee is probably the sugar habit I have had to work hardest on.

    Flavored coffee creamer can add up quickly, especially when you are pouring straight from the bottle.

    For a long time, I was not measuring it. And if I do not measure it, I can easily use a lot more than I think.

    So one of the simplest things I do now is measure it.

    If I am going to use coffee creamer, I know how many tablespoons I am putting into my coffee instead of free-pouring it.

    That alone can make a big difference.

    You can also experiment with reducing the amount little by little.

    Another option is half-and-half or cream with vanilla extract. It is not going to taste as sweet as flavored creamer, but you still get that creamy coffee.

    If you need a little sweetness, you can add a small amount of pure maple syrup yourself. Maple syrup is still added sugar, but you are deciding exactly how much goes into your cup instead of having it built into a flavored product.

    You could also try:

    • Cinnamon
    • Vanilla extract
    • Unsweetened milk or nondairy milk
    • Half-and-half plus a smaller amount of your usual creamer
    • Gradually reducing your usual creamer over time

    You do not have to wake up tomorrow and suddenly drink black coffee if you hate black coffee.

    Sometimes progress really is just measuring what you already use and slowly cutting back. That is still progress.

    Read the Label – Especially on Foods That Look “Healthy”

    This is probably one of the most practical things you can start doing today.

    Look at the Added Sugars line on the Nutrition Facts label.

    You do not need to become obsessed with every gram. You just need to start noticing.

    Foods where I pay particular attention include:

    • Flavored yogurt
    • Coffee creamer
    • Granola
    • Instant oatmeal
    • Protein bars
    • Nut butter
    • Salad dressing
    • Pasta sauce
    • Smoothies and bottled smoothie drinks
    • Cereal
    • Snack bars

    Once you start looking, you may be surprised too.

    But I actually find that encouraging.

    Information gives you choices.

    You can compare two yogurts and choose the one with less added sugar.

    You can use less creamer.

    You can buy an unsweetened version and add your own fruit.

    You can decide that one food is absolutely worth it and enjoy it.

    That is so much more sustainable than trying to create a long list of foods you are never “allowed” to eat.

    meal prep for weight loss

    Meal Prep Is How I Make This Easier Before the Craving Starts

    This might be the most important part of this entire article.

    I do not believe in making myself rely on willpower all day.

    If I know chocolate or highly processed snacks are a problem for me when they are sitting in the house, I usually do not keep them around as everyday foods.

    If I do have sweets in the house, I portion them.

    And at the same time, I make the foods I want to eat incredibly easy to grab.

    • I prep fruit.
    • I portion smoothie ingredients.
    • I make individual jars of overnight oats.
    • I keep cottage cheese and yogurt in the refrigerator.
    • I cook sweet potatoes ahead.
    • I make hard-boiled eggs or other protein options.
    • I prep lunches that actually have enough protein to keep me full.

    Being prepared keeps my goals top of mind, but it also solves a practical problem: I am not standing in front of the pantry starving and trying to talk myself into making a good choice.

    The choice is already there.

    That is the same reason meal prep became such a powerful part of my weight-loss journey in the first place. See my how to meal prep for weight loss guide.

    What to Do if You Keep Slipping Back Into Sugar

    First, do not turn one treat into a story about how you “blew it.” You did not.

    If you had cake, you had cake.

    If you had candy, you had candy.

    Move on.

    I am much more interested in what my regular habits look like than what I ate at one party.

    If I notice that sugar has started becoming an everyday habit again, that is when I get intentional.

    I look at where it is showing up.

    I start measuring.

    I read labels.

    I make sure I am getting enough protein.

    I prep my food.

    And sometimes I give myself a simple 10-day challenge around one habit.

    Ten days feels manageable to me. It gives me enough time to get focused and prove to myself that I can make the change without pretending I have to be perfect forever.

    You do not need to change everything today.

    Choose one thing.

    • Maybe it is measuring your coffee creamer.
    • Maybe it is changing your afternoon snack.
    • Maybe it is adding protein to breakfast.
    • Maybe it is checking the added sugar on the yogurt you buy every week.

    Start there. Then build on it. That is how I have made the changes that actually stuck.

    Simple Sugar-Cutting Swaps to Try This Week

    • Instead of flavored yogurt, try plain or lower-sugar Greek yogurt with fruit.
    • Instead of eating fruit alone, pair it with peanut butter, cheese, Greek yogurt, cottage cheese, or nuts.
    • Instead of a fruit-only smoothie, add cottage cheese, Greek yogurt, protein powder, chia seeds, nut butter, or avocado.
    • Instead of free-pouring flavored coffee creamer, measure it first and gradually reduce it if you want to.
    • Instead of a packaged sweet breakfast, make protein overnight oats or eggs with fruit.
    • Instead of keeping candy on the counter, keep fruit washed and visible and portion treats if you want them in the house.
    • Instead of trying to be sugar-free forever, pick one added-sugar habit to work on for the next 10 days.

    A Final Reminder

    You do not have to give up every sweet food to make meaningful changes.

    You also do not have to wait until Monday, January, or some perfect time to start.

    • Pay attention.
    • Read the label.
    • Prep the foods you want to eat.
    • Add protein and healthy fats.
    • Portion the treats you want to enjoy.

    And if you have a day where you eat more sugar than you planned, keep going.

    That is what has worked for me.

    The goal is not to “quit sugar” and never think about it again.

    The goal is to build habits that make the healthier choice easier most of the time.

    Did This Help?

    If you are working on cutting back on added sugar too, I would love to hear what your biggest challenge is. Coffee creamer? Afternoon snacks? Desserts? Something else? Leave a comment and let me know.

    Sharing is caring!

    24021 shares
    • Share
    • Tweet

    Healthy Lifestyle and Weight Loss

    About Tammy Overhoff

    Hi, I’m Tammy Overhoff, a busy mom, wife, and entrepreneur. I am the owner, author, and recipe developer here at Organize Yourself Skinny. Since 2011 Organize Yourself Skinny has become a trusted resource for clean eating recipes to meal prep, reviews, and lifestyle hacks to help you fit healthy habits and routines into your busy schedule. Check out my online shop Reset & Flourish for all of my eBooks, Guides, and Bundles!

    Primary Sidebar

    Hi, I’m Tammy Overhoff, a busy mom, wife, and entrepreneur. I am the owner, author, and recipe developer here at Organize Yourself Skinny. Since 2011 Organize Yourself Skinny has become a trusted resource for clean eating meal prep recipes, reviews, and lifestyle hacks to help you fit healthy habits and routines into your busy schedule. Check out my online shop Reset & Flourish for all of my eBooks, Guides, and Bundles!

    More about me →

    [otw_shortcode_widget_shortcode shortcode_type="widget_shortcode_search"][/otw_shortcode_widget_shortcode]

    Soup Recipes

    • overhead picture of pasta fagioli
      Pasta Fagioli Recipe (Olive Garden Copycat)
    • Healthy zuppa toscana soup in a bowl.
      Zuppa Toscana Recipe (Healthy Olive Garden Copycat)
    • healthy potato soup recipe
      Healthy Potato Soup
    • healthy stuffed pepper soup
      Stuffed Pepper Soup

    Helpful Reviews

    • Tammy Overhoff with her box from Thrive Market
      Thrive Market Review 2026: These Products Make It Worth It!
    • Tammy Overhoff holding a package of butcher box chicken things and butcher box bacon for her butcher box review
      ButcherBox Review 2026: Is It Actually Worth It?
    • Tammy overhoff holding her daily harvest box for her review
      Daily Harvest Review 2026: The Best Daily Harvest Meals!
    • Tammy Overhoff holding her green chef box that she will review
      Green Chef Review 2023: The Best Green Chef Meals
    • Privacy Policy
    • Disclaimer
    • FAQS
    • Fulfillment & Refund Policy

    Footer

    ↑ back to top

    Copyright © 2022 Organize Yourself Skinny

    24021 shares